Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] Welcome to The Road to VA Compensation Benefits, a podcast by Hill and Ponton. Join us as we interview experienced VA attorneys and get practical tips on your VA claims. 0:17 [on-hold music] Now your host, Partner Matthew Hill. So let's see. 0:35 Hi, I'm P and T. When VA changes the rating criteria for a condition, can VA reduce me based on the new criteria, or am I grandfathered? The answer is you should be grandfathered. 0:45 You, you should be rated for at the time at which you were rated. I've seen the VA try to reduce people. 0:52 I strongly recommend to veterans never to file another claim on that issue, frankly, or any issue if they're P and T, because it's harder to get more benefits. 1:00 If there's a chance for special monthly compensation, that could be different, but still there's the law and then there's what the VA does. 1:06 So I would just caution against applying again, but the law states that just because the rating criteria changes, they can't retrospectively go back and change all those issues. 1:16 All right, so I had William ask, "Can SMCT spawn at the VA even if the claim wasn't filed? Have proof of diagnosis in Nexus. I just didn't file it at the VA for ANA." So we're mixing around, uh, legal terms here. 1:33 If you are going to the BVA for a TBI claim or a TBI increase claim, both of those, both the claim itself and the increase, they implicitly contain a claim for maximum rating. 1:46 And a maximum rating in your case would show SMCT. So the answer is, if you had the claim for TBI or TBI increase, then yes. 1:55 There can be a claim for SMC, but an SMC claim is inherently part of the underlying claim for a benefit. 2:03 All right, KY: "Do I have a legal right to ask C&P examiner to do a supplemental report to address a related medical issue that I want her to address?" No, you do not. 2:15 The VA medical examiner is gonna narrowly tailor their exam to what is specifically requested from the VA adjudicator. So sometimes I've seen them actually not even address secondary issues. 2:27 So if a vet has a back problem, they won't address the radiculopathy, the pain shooting down a leg or an arm due to the back or diabetes, you know, if they have a nephropathy, a problem with their kidney. 2:39 Sometimes I'll see them say, "No, that's outside of the scope of what I was asked to do. I was asked to look at whether or not the veteran has diabetes." Ms. 2:46 Anderson: "How can I connect decreased kidney function to as secondary to UTI?" Well, you need forensic doctor to connect that for you. 2:55 If you go to the VA C&P exam, and they say, "No, it's not connected, it's caused by, you know, something else," then you definitely have to have your doctor go out and say it. Mr. 3:03 Casper: "If a veteran decides to retain your law firm services, how do you guys handle the medical aspect if we're in different state? Do you all have your own doctors that will evaluate us?" 3:12 So when I first started out, I used to look for a doctor in every state, every location where a veteran was, just because I thought they needed to see them. 3:19 And then as the case law evolved, it became apparent that in-person visit is not necessary, and what's necessary is that the doctor know what they're talking about. The doctor needs to be competent. 3:29 And so for my firm, what we've done is we've developed a relationship with doctors all over the US who we find to be very well educated, very qualified, and they understand the VA process. 3:39 So with our firm, we don't send vets out if we do not have to. Most of the time what we do is a FaceTime or, you know, some kind of Zoom or something, and then the doctor has all the vet's medical records. 3:51 They, they talk to the vet about it. They talk to a spouse or other family members about how their service-connected disability affects the veteran. So we don't typically do that. 3:59 There are instances where if the veteran has service-connected issue that for some reason they need to be seen, we would try to find a doctor locally or an orthopedic issue that required a range of motion, we would do that. 4:10 So to answer the question, in a way, we make it as comfortable as possible for the veteran. They never have to leave their house, and with that, we get the most qualified doctors to actually see their claim. 4:19 Lucy: "I just got rated five out of six on PTSD scale. What can I expect in that alone? Have more issues in progress. Vietnam veteran." I don't know what a five out of six on the PTSD scale is. 4:32 Typically, they have scales for the treating doctors. They have scales in-house, meaning in the hospital, that they use to do a quick evaluation of a veteran. Those scales are not ones that the VA adjudicators will use. 4:44 A five out of six, you know, on a C&P exam, there's six or at least different pages, so I'm not quite sure how that would compute, Lucy. 4:51 But I would say that you're dealing with a serious issue here that you definitely need to both get help on and get benefits for. 4:57 So make sure that if you haven't seen C&P and doctor, that you talk not just about flashbacks, night terrors, those things, but also any issues with anger or isolation or just not being socialized or being around others. 5:11 "Can BVA see that TBI diagnosed and test with Nexus without having it in the claim? The reason why is because when SMC is introduced, should the judge consider SMCT or R1?" 5:25 If the TBI is not something claimed or the TBI isn't implicitly claimed, so let's say the veteran applies for a mental health diagnosis and it turns out that the veteran's underlying issue is TBI, then that would be something where the VA would have to address that. 5:40 If it gets to the board and they say there's a test with a diagnosis and a nexus, that to me says that it's been developed, that it's actually been part of the claim. 5:48 So I would say yes, the board has to address that because it's actively being processed by the VA. So if that's the case, then SMC would be in play. SMCT would be in play, not SMC(R1).R-one is just for regular SMC. 6:04 It's, it's pretty confusing, but SMCT, you can go from SMC eight in attendance at SMCL up to SMCT. It's, it's a different process in, in how it jumps. 6:14 So you would be looking for SMCT, I guess, is the short way I would say that. Ben Thornley: "I have a hundred percent. What is the amount of money that I will receive?" 6:21 If you google VA comp rates, you should be taken to that page. That's where you get two rates, and a hundred percent would depend on if you have a spouse, if you have kids, if you have dependent parents. 6:32 There's a lot of different variables there that would affect the rate. "For HRL, is VA required to call me if I wrote in the form requesting a phone call?" They're required to. Do they all the time? No. 6:42 But yes, they should be giving you a call. That typically happens pretty fast too. 6:46 With the HLR, higher-level review cases, they happen rather quickly, four weeks to sometimes three months at the most, which is for VA, so that's moved pretty fast. 6:55 John K.: "While looking into my current claim, I was told I was needed to address old claims, but not to do so until after these claims are taken care of." Here's how I say it. I, I don't care when what claim was filed. 7:06 What I would do is sit and look down with a VSO or with a family member, I think family member is actually better, and say, "What are your strongest claims? 7:15 Do you have a hearing loss claim that you wanna file, an elbow claim, a knee, something with your back? Which one of those cause the max amount of problems for you?" That's what I would focus on. 7:24 You know, you could battle for ten years for tinnitus, and your max rating is gonna be ten percent. So I would look and say, "What are the issues that are affecting me the most?" and file those. 7:33 I don't care if they were new issues or old issues, but those are the ones you wanna pursue. "What if I didn't claim SMCT?" Okay, so special monthly compensation can be something you claim separately. 7:45 If you are already rated, you have a max rating, you can go in and say, "I should be filed for special monthly compensation." 7:50 But special monthly compensation is actually an inferred claim that starts from the date at which you are eligible. 7:57 So just to break that down, the easiest one is you become a hundred percent, and you have a separate group of ratings that combine to sixty percent. At that point, you're titled to what's called SMCS. 8:08 If you never file a claim for SMCS until, let's say, ten years later, say, "Hey, look, I just found out I was entitled to these benefits," well, the VA has to take that all the way back. 8:16 This is a rare instance where the VA has to go far back because that claim was sitting there, and it was never adjudicated by the VA. 8:22 So if you have a claim for TBI, SMCT is a special monthly compensation that applies just for those with traumatic brain injuries. 8:30 If you have a claim for TBI and you get a max rating, and then it's determined that you actually need aid and attendance due to that, and then you can show that there's someone who basically takes care of you and gives you medical care, and even though they're not a medical doctor, then at that point, you can get SMCT, but you don't have to have claimed it, just have to be focused on the underlying claim there. 8:50 John K.: "At a C&P exam, how do I get it documented that range of motion pain can be worse when it might be that day? Or is that a buddy letter?" I would write a buddy letter. 9:01 You write a letter, I have your friend write a letter, your wife write a letter, your mom write a letter, everybody write a letter, because they are gonna screw that up. You tell them that. 9:08 You say, "Hey, look, wow, look, I'm, I'm getting amazing range of motion today. It doesn't hurt." And you say to the doc, "This isn't normal. This isn't normally how it goes. Normally, I'm much worse." 9:16 Along those lines, this thing that works against you that, that I see a lot is that vets go into these exams having medicated, either taking, you know, something as little as Tylenol or something as strong as oxycodone or, or whatever they're taking on a normal basis, and they're taking that because they can't move, they can't get around. 9:33 I strongly advise not to take that because if you take that, how can the VA tell what your range of motion on pain is? You've dulled the pain. 9:41 You've gotten rid of the pain, which is good for you, but it's not good to show how awful and how severe your benefits are. So buddy letters, I am a big fan of those, John. 9:50 Combat Craig: "Can you give us your thoughts about the VA putting the DBQs back up on their website?" I think it's a good thing. I wanna know what they're asking my vets. 9:58 I mean, I, I see that because we ask for the C file once it comes through. [laughs] Here's the catch. I don't get my experts to fill those out because I think they're crap. 10:07 I think they're these, you know, check-the-box, little, "Does the veteran have this?" check, especially for mental health. Do they get mad? Do they have nightmares frequently? 10:15 So I don't necessarily use them, but what I do like to do is I like to have those questions so that our experts can look at them and say, "What do you think of these?" 10:23 And our experts will actually write out, like, a long narrative, you know, multi-pages versus just a check-the-box. 10:28 So I think it's good because if you don't have an expert, then hopefully you can at least take that to your treating doctor because that's a lot easier than having them write from nothing. 10:37 So I, I think it is a good thing. My thought overall is the more transparent the VA is, the better the process is gonna work. 10:44 My organization that I'm with, the National Organization of Veterans Advocates, fought tooth and nail to get that to be done, and again, it-- to me, it comes back to transparency. 10:53 TBI claim at the BVA, affidavit and treatment records show daily back-hip therapy with caregiver. Also have medicine. I'm rated at forty percent for back. 11:02 Will judge see this also as an R-one, uh, ANA based on daily therapy? You gotta get up to a hundred percent first, and then you can start talking about ANA, and then you go from there. 11:12 But if you have daily hip therapy, I mean, that clearly to me, ANA, but you still need to get your underlying rating up.All right, Oldest Dirt Veteran: If I have a lawyer working on my claim, can I file new claims? 11:23 I don't like it when veterans file new claims and on their attorney, because I wanna know what all is being filed, what stage it's at. I mean, can you have the attorney filing your claims? 11:32 Sure, but the attorney might have a reason for you to not file a new claim at that point. That to me says, maybe you wanna do it on your own. 11:38 If you don't feel like the case is going in the angle you want, then you could call the attorney and say, "Hey, look, this is not going where I want, uh, let's just disengage services," and you go from there. 11:46 Personally speaking, we rarely file new claims. 11:49 I can't give you hard data on this, but I've found that those new claims will slow down the claims that I thought were good to begin with that we should pursue to get the vet the max benefits. 11:59 So it's a pretty rare instance that I would file new claims. But again, if you're s- feel strongly about it, attorney doesn't wanna do it, say, "Hey, look, this isn't working for me," and go your own way. 12:07 Charles again, service records. I have about six hundred pages of personal records, but cannot get service-connected to save my life. 12:14 So somehow you would need to take those personnel records, find the event that caused what's going on with you right now, and then you need to get a medical person, a doctor, PA, nurse practitioner, to connect the two to say, "Look, I've read these records. 12:28 I see what he has now. Here's the relationship between the two, and this is why it should be connected." 12:33 So it's not something you can do for yourself, even if you have the smoking gun, if you will, in the VA's record showing what happened. Why does the VA deny me for everything? 12:42 These examiners of the VA never tell the truth [laughs] about PTSD problems for Vietnam veterans. I hear you. 12:47 The majority of the veterans that we have the opportunity to represent are Vietnam vets, and when I look what is put down on particular PTSD C&P exams, I don't feel like they do a good job. 12:58 Again, this goes back to putting those C&P exams out, so people can see them. If you read them, they're really not impressive. For a mental health exam, it's a very subjective problem. 13:09 If you look at a back, they wanna look at range of motion, which is literally a number. With mental health, it, it varies between person to person. So I can't answer that for you. 13:17 I would recommend to everyone who's going to a C&P exam to search through their database and find the actual exam, the template of the exam for which you're going to see. 13:27 That way, you will actually know the answers to the questions. You'll know what they're saying, why they're asking you, and you'll know where you should fit in there. Or so if they say, "Are you a number one?" 13:37 And you jump on number one, well, when you're really a number three, they're gonna try to use that against you that you said you're number one. 13:43 I do have a Nexus letter, and I still get denied for no complaints and service. It's not just complaints. It could be an event. 13:50 If you were on a base in Iraq and you saw somebody get blown up just three blocks from you, that's an event. Even didn't even have directly to you. 13:58 If you're in service and you're a boxer and you get knocked down eighteen different times, you get knocked out four different times, maybe you didn't even go see the doc, but at the same time, that's an event. 14:09 So you gotta find instances, not just, you know, it's nice if you have a complaint in a medical record showing what happened. That's beautiful. That does not always happen. 14:17 So you gotta figure out what was an event, what happened as a result of the event. Somebody got knocked out, boxer, back to that example. 14:24 Did it turn into a point to where the veteran's performance went down because he was losing memory, just wasn't reacting as quickly? Those are the kind of things you look for as far as an event. 14:35 Suggest claimants engage WP only if they've been denied a claim, or do you work with initial filers or waiting to file an updated claim? Okay, Tim Sherman, I think you're talking about us, uh, WP is H&P. 14:48 I do not suggest you engage me, my firm, or any other law firm for initial claim, for a reopening claim. 14:55 Frankly, even if you're filing an appeal and you feel like you have the evidence that they're talking about and they ignored it or evidence that updates what you have, I say you do that yourself. 15:03 You shouldn't have to pay someone to get the benefits you deserve. 15:06 And that sounds weird coming from me 'cause that's how I make a living, it's helping benefits, but most of the vets we help are Vietnam vets because they've been filing for decades, and they've been getting denied and screwed over and not getting the ratings that they should. 15:18 So when one of those folks come to me, they've got a lot of negative evidence against them, usually in the form of C&P exams, and they need somebody who's gonna fight back with the law, with medical experts. 15:29 So I would never recommend going straight to an attorney. If you have an attorney who's courting you, I'd be leery of that. So no, don't come to us if you haven't filed. The VA is supposed to help you. 15:37 I'm jaded, but the VA has a duty to assist you, and I never see where they assist a veteran and get it right because the veteran doesn't wanna appeal. 15:45 But the VA is supposed to go get all your records, they're supposed to get your treating medical records, they're supposed to send you their C&P exam if need be. 15:52 And so they have an obligation to do this right the first time. 15:56 John F.: If you don't have service records due to the old school thought of suck it up and wipe the dirt on it, what can still assist in linking back to service time? Buddy statements. 16:07 If you can get statements from those who served from you, that, that's the best way. If you can show that performance went down, that's another way. 16:13 If you can show combat issue, if you can show that your base was attacked, that's one way. Just because you don't have medical records does not mean your case is dead in the water. 16:21 Harder to prove, no doubt, but there are other ways, and, you know, even if you don't know anyone, not speaking with anyone currently you served with, Facebook is amazing for this purpose on finding those whom you served with and trying to get back in touch, and that way, hopefully getting a, a buddy statement. 16:34 On average, how long are appeals taking to BVA without a hearing? They're saying it's only taking several months without a hearing. I don't see that. [laughs] I see at least a year, if I'm lucky. So I don't know. 16:46 I do know that the BVA is getting more and more backlogged right now, and it's gonna get to the point to where it's many, many years like it used to be, because most vets are taking their claim up to the board. 16:56 Right now, I would say under a year without a hearing, without adding evidence. Army George: They have my severance pay, early retirement recruitment all messed up. 17:05 Department of Veterans Affairs saying I owe a bunch of money when I don't. Can you guys help me with that? Unfortunately, we don't handle those kind of claims. 17:13 In a backhanded way, we get these claims when we get a vet awarded benefits. The benefits won't go to our veteran. 17:19 It'll just sit there, and this goes to the DoD, who looks at severance pay, who looks at early retirement recruitmentAnd they're the ones that say how much of the veteran's retro benefits should be withheld. 17:30 We have tried to work with them for ten years trying to figure out who's responsible with that, how we do internal appeals, and we've gotten nowhere. So we're not your firm for that, unfortunately. 17:40 I thought a lawyer could only work on denied claims. Denied or reopened claims in some certain circumstances. 17:45 Not as clear now because the claim to reopen, if it's within a year, an attorney can help you, but if it's not, the attorney cannot charge a fee. 17:54 Tim Sherman, thoughts on whether there's a future for PTSD claimants to be denied gun ownership rights with some of the recent proposed gun re- legislation, specifically with relation to mental health. 18:05 I have not seen that come to the VA sphere yet. Doesn't mean that it can't. I don't deny that, but the VA can't come and get your guns. They have no federal, state authority to do that. 18:17 If you're a hundred percent, what's your income cap? If I'm making a hundred K a year on rental properties, do I lose my disability? So these are two distinct questions. 18:25 You don't have an income cap if you're a hundred percent for one disability or combined a hundred percent. There are issues of income if you do have unemployability. 18:33 But even if you have unemployability and you're making a hundred K a year from rental properties, you would not lose your disability. So neither a hundred percent straight or unemployability. 18:43 Unless you're the one building the properties, doing all the maintenance of the properties, you know, basically spending forty hours a week doing that, the unemployability could come in question. 18:52 The hundred percent would only come into question if the VA said, "Well, we think you've improved. We think your back's better. We think that your leg's better or, or your shoulder," or whatever. 19:00 They wouldn't necessarily come after you for a financial reason if you're straight a hundred percent. But if they say, "Well, look, he's doing all these things, he should be better." 19:08 But if it's just a hundred K on passive rental income, meaning you're just getting the money as it comes in for rent, maybe you're, you know, changing a light bulb, maybe you're the one who does all the coordination of who comes in and who goes out, that's all passive stuff. 19:21 That's not really something they should be coming after you on. AB, I heard plantar fasciitis will lower down the percentage from fifty to thirty. When is it going to apply? 19:30 I've been rated initially at fifty, but I'm still on active duty. My understanding is that they're in the question and comment period. This could be another several months. 19:39 Usually, it's about four to six months from when it starts, depending on how many people comment on it. So I don't know. In fact, it's a brand-new rating. Very well they could reduce it to thirty. 19:47 So that's just something to watch for. VA C&P examiner wrote a nexus to service for fibromyalgia, and VRO denied the claim. Now on appeal to the board. 19:56 I've seen that, unfortunately, quite a few times where the VA asks for an exam, gets an exam, and totally ignores the exam. So it's a good thing you are appealing it to the board. 20:04 If this is a Gulf War issue, they just screw this up left and right. They'll say that the fibromyalgia was identified as a diagnosis and therefore it cannot be Gulf War because you have a diagnosis. 20:15 When the regulation for the Gulf War specifically states that fibromyalgia is a disorder that is known to be related to Gulf War. So that's one I think you definitely need to appeal. 20:25 I find that the board doesn't get confused as easily, and they understand the law on those issues. Kevin S. 20:31 Why can VA mental health examiner get away with notating a hundred percent level symptoms in the narrative, but not checking the corresponding boxes related to the symptoms? I see this all the time. 20:40 It's maddening, and that's the thing about their little box. 20:43 You know, they check this, and then they put two sentences down there, uh, and the VA examiners will pretty much only look at the box and say, "Oh, they checked that, then that's where it is." 20:51 So I would appeal that and say, "Look, this is actually what the doctor said. He checked your box here, but he said this." At the least you should be entitled to a new C&P exam. 21:00 You could also look to see if you could find another doctor to review that, to talk to you and give you another exam. How long does it take a lawyer to get a claims file? Totally depends. It could be three months. 21:10 It could be a year. Some attorneys have access to their e-folder system, the VA, and so that could be a couple of months. It just depends. 21:18 In our firm, we have to file a lot of appeals, threaten lawsuits for the VA to actually send it over. So it's, it's a frustrating process. Should be a lot quicker than it is. John K. 21:28 In regards to this broken process of appeals and poor medical treatment at VA Medical Center, can depression be found due to this? How can vets feel good about themselves in such a negative treatment? 21:38 Depression can be, frankly, secondary to almost any disability, and what I found with vets, let's say they have a bad back, they're going through the system. 21:45 Well, depression typically starts before the VA process starts, meaning that their disability has completely altered their life. They're not able to do what they used to do. 21:53 They aren't the person they thought they were, and so depression starts to creep in, and then, yes, you can file a claim secondary for depression. 21:59 It can happen any time, so if the back claim is ongoing appeal, and then it's not being service-connected, and it's frustrating, then yeah, that could be part of the claim there as well, that VA has caused a secondary depression. 22:09 If I was rejected for IBS presumptive to Southeast Asia due to no diagnosis and I am diagnosed in the future, is it automatically approved? 22:17 If you're diagnosed, then basically, yeah, they've said on those other issues that we concede that you were in the service area, but you just don't have a diagnosis, then yeah. 22:26 If you're in Southwest Asia, you can be service-connected for Gulf War syndrome, basically meaning that you have a disability the VA can't diagnose. That is Gulf War syndrome. 22:35 So it doesn't work in Southeast Asia, but if you were over in the Gulf, that does work there. 22:40 Mermaid Mia, when you have TIU, does owning your own business cancel out your business if you make more than fourteen thousand? So this is what I was going back to. 22:49 If you are the one doing all the work in your business, essentially you're your own employee, yeah, that's a problem. 22:54 If you have a business where you have others working for you, you're doing work, but you're doing it when you can and how you can in a way that if you were the employee of someone else, you'd be fired because you're not actually doing the job on time, then that doesn't matter, meaning that you can make more than fourteen thousand dollars. 23:12 So it's more of is it sheltered, meaning like you created the job for yourself or somebody in your family created jobs with you, or is it passive like rental income? 23:20 So that's what you wanna be considering there.Filthy Rich exclusive. I was denied for PTSD two days ago. 23:27 I had a Nexus and a C&P exam, which were all great, but the VA said they could not verify my stressor, but I know it happened. 23:34 When they say they couldn't verify your stressor, again, you gotta go back to your service or medical records. Does it show a problem there? Service records, were you in a theater of war when it happened? 23:42 And did the VA C&P examiner said, "Hey, this is related to his time at theater of war." That's a solid case. That case is done. You just gotta appeal it. AJ Mack, I just had a C&P exam on Tuesday for TBI. 23:54 I was called back by the LHI asking me to take a PTSD review today. Are they calling me because the examiner requested a C&P exam? 24:02 That's probably why they are, and, and what's going on there is a lot of times TBI and PTSD are so intertwined that one can't see it at first, and then once the veteran sees a doctor, they look and they say, "Well, I think there's two things going on here, TBI and PTSD," or somehow it's all just PTSD. 24:19 But the point is, they're breaking that out, and hopefully that's a good thing because that would be two separate ratings for it. These are great questions. Hope it's been some help for you guys. 24:28 It's great to see that some of you have actually gotten some help from these, so thank you for that. We appreciate, again, you coming on and being a part of this and appreciate your service. Thank you so much. 24:39 [on-hold music] Thank you for tuning in to The Road to VA Compensation Benefits, a podcast by Hill and Ponton. 25:00 If you would like help with your VA claim or want more veterans disability content, please visit our website, www.hillandponton.com. 25:11 Also, don't forget to follow us on social media, facebook.com/hillandponton, as well as youtube.com/hillandponton. [on-hold music]