Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, welcome everyone to this week's YouTube live. 0:20 Today you've got Ursula McCabe and Shannon Brewer to answer all of your questions. Uh, Shannon, you ready to get into it? Absolutely. All right, let's get into it. Are you going first or am I going first? 0:35 I'm happy to go first. Okay. Uh, our first question's from Angel Marrero. "Greetings. At the suggestion of VA, I applied and was granted TDIU, which opened an e-eval of my 70% PTSD and denied my increase. 0:49 I now have a private DBQ and Nexus, but submitted it under an 0995 instead of HLR. Will this be a problem and do I have to do another C&P exam? Thank you." It is not a problem. 1:02 Uh, the 0995 form is just a supplemental appeal, and you're allowed to submit new evidence, so you've, you've done what you need to do. I can't say they're not gonna give you another C&P exam. 1:13 I wish I could, but they order them when they want them. Uh, they may ask for another one. 1:19 Um, a lot of times when you submit favorable evidence, they're gonna ask their own doctors to review it or to, uh, look at both opinions and decide which one's better. Kind of, you know, it, it is... 1:34 I don't think it's always necessary. I very often think it's not necessary, but my advice is typically if a C&P exam is ordered, go to it. It, get... Otherwise, they use it as an excuse to deny your claim. 1:45 So I would say go to the exam if they order one. Uh, you know, you may get lucky and they won't, but I would suspect they're probably gonna give you one. Ursula, do you agree? I mean, I, I 100% agree. 1:59 Um, what I would caution, not caution, but say is if you're trying to get TDIU and you're filing an appeal, it shouldn't really be for an increased rating. 2:11 I mean, it is, but make sure that it's the unemployability that's on appeal, not the rating of the PTSD. If it's the rating of the PTSD, I can almost guarantee you're gonna get another C&P exam. 2:21 But if you can get a vocational expert opinion or something in there that shows your functional limitations, your occupational limitations, that's gonna help with your unemployability. 2:33 But yes, I, I agree with everything Shannon said. Sherman Barker, "What is de novo dino- and can I do a supplemental claim?" 2:47 So de novo review is something, it's a, a standard of review that VA does. So when you do a supplemental claim 2:55 and they make a decision, um, and you go and file a higher level review, you can, it's supposed to be a de novo review, meaning the 3:05 decision review officer doesn't have to take any consideration into the previous decision. 3:12 So they're allowed to look at all of the evidence, all of the file, and go, "I agree," or, "I disagree, and because of this, we're gonna go ahead and turn this around." 3:23 So that's what a de novo review is, meaning their own review of all of the evidence and coming up with their own determination. Um, and can I do a supplemental claim? 3:35 Yes, you absolutely can if you have been previously denied for a condition and you have new and relevant evidence. 3:42 So if you were denied, um, six months ago or five years ago, let's say for sleep apnea, and you wanna reopen it, you can absolutely reopen that claim with new and relevant evidence using the supplemental claim. Shannon? 3:59 Yeah, I would say the, the beauty of the AMA, uh, appeal system, the new VA system of the past few years, you can always keep going. As, anytime you have new evidence, you can always file a supplemental claim. 4:12 You can reopen, you can appeal. All you need for a supplemental claim is something new, and it can be as, it can be as simple as a statement that has information that you didn't say before. 4:24 So a supplemental claim is, is always an option. Okay, this one's from Hoosier Den. "First, thanks for all you do. I appreciate all your time and efforts that you all put into these Q&As. 4:40 Question on mental health: I filed for PTSD and was denied. However, I was diagnosed with major depressive disorder with anxious distress. Should the VA have changed my claim to MDD and fully developed? 4:53 There was no attempt to service connect on the VA's part. Thanks again." Yes. 4:57 Uh, so the way VA is supposed to treat mental health claims, they should always be a claim for all mental disorders, because you're not a doctor and you file a claim for the symptoms. 5:11 Um, and particularly with mental health claims, you can see three different doctors and get three different diagnoses. The, the, the diagnoses do overlap. They are very fluid. 5:22 Uh, the symptoms are very often, you can find, uh, mental health symptoms, the same symptoms w- for more than one diagnosis. 5:30 So VA should always be treating any claim for mental health as a claim for all mental health disorders, and they should be developing for that. I say should. That does not mean they always do. 5:43 Um, they, they very often get that right, but sometimes they don't. So if they, if they didn't, um, y- unfortunately, your option is to appeal. 5:52 You know, but, um, or to file a new claim, but I, I, I am always a fan of appeal. 5:57 So you can appeal, um, the condition that they denied to include the dis- conditions that they didn't address.I am very much a fan of an acquired psychiatric disorder- Yes... to include MVD and PTSD. 6:15 Kind of gets all of them. Exactly. Yep. Ranger175, part one of two. "I'm rated 10% for DDD, 10% radiculopathy bilateral, 10% lumbar strain. 6:32 I put in for sciatica pa- para- paralysis bilateral and degenerative arthritis of the spine. 6:41 If the sciatica and de- degenerative arthritis are approved, will they rate these separately or together and increase the rating? If approved and separate rating, will I get bilateral factor for both?" 6:53 Um, let's go back to the first part just so I can answer everything. So sciatica is rated the same or under the radiculopathy, um, of the lower extremities. 7:08 So the way that they do it is it depends on what that, that 10% radiculopathy is for and what nerves have been affected, um, 'cause that's how they figure it out. 7:18 So if you were, if you have multiple nerves that are affected that are different, you could get individual ratings for those based on the nerve involvement. Um, so yes, you could get that. 7:31 If it is in both, yes, you should get the bilateral factor. Um, the DDD is disc degeneration. Um, and I, I think it's gonna kind of be the same, 7:47 it's gonna be pyramiding if they service-connect it and rate you again on the spine if you've got the DDD. So those are kind of the same condition with the same symptomology. Um, so it just depends on, on that. 8:00 And you've also got the lumbar s- um, strain. Um, so I don't know that the arthritis will get you anywhere else without knowing more. Shannon? No, I kind of agree. 8:15 When the, the arthritis of the spine is gonna be maybe a 10%, but you've already got that. 8:20 You're already rated for degenerative dis- disc disease, and degenerative arthritis is really the same, it- it- it's the same effect. So it's not gonna be a separate rating. 8:29 The only thing I see that might be a separate rating is, like you said, if, if your radiculopathy is, is sciatic already, they're not gonna give you another sciatic, uh, rating. But if, but there are other nerves. 8:43 Uh, a lot of times we see sciatic and femoral. So, um, it, it really depends what nerves are affected. 8:49 But it looks to me like you're filing a claim for something you already have, uh, service-connected, so maybe an increased rating, but I don't think a separate rating, unless I'm missing something there. I agree. 9:05 I think we got all those, those answered. Yep. Okay, this one's from Miss Ambiguity. "Explain how to argue earlier effective date. 9:14 If VA had knowledge of the condition in your service treatment records and vet applied for a condition much later, heart condition revealed during high blood pressure rating. 9:25 Spouse married 22 years then divorced vet who was 100%, remarries in 1990 at age 54, then becomes a widow." Ca- okay, these are two separate questions. Uh, let's go back to the first question. 9:38 How to argue earlier effective date. So just because they had knowledge of it doesn't mean that you filed a claim for it. 9:48 So in order, the way the VA ratings work, the way the VA regulations work, if you didn't file a claim, VA is not, VA is not gonna go back and say, "Well, you had this in your service treatment records, so we're gonna give you an earlier effective date for that." 10:02 So, um, unfortunately, if, if you didn't file the claim un- until you, uh, uh, when you're saying you applied for it much later, that's gonna be your, your effective date. 10:14 I, unless there's some kind of exception, um, possi- under NEMA rules, if, if you are a Vietnam veteran, there might be a way to go back. But outside of that, um, there's, you can't go back before you file the claim. 10:28 So I, I'm not aware of a, a way that you would be able to do that, unless you are a Vietnam vet. Okay, let's go to the next question by Miss Ambiguity. Okay. 10:38 "Spouse married 22 years then divorced vet who was 100%, remarries in 1990 at age 54, and then becomes a widow. Can she apply for DIC from the first husband? Divorce was due to vet's PTSD." Ugh. So... 10:56 I would say no. I'm gonna say no. Um, I think you're- Well, it depends who, who remarried. If he remarried, no. His new wife would be entitled to the D- DIC. If she remarried- Sounds like she did 11:14 ... there used to be, 11:17 and correct me if I'm wrong, there used to be a rule that said that if you remarried, you were no longer entitled to the DIC unless it, or, or if you were divorced or separated but it was due to the veteran's mental health or condition, then there, there were some exceptions that were there. 11:35 There are. So this is something that I don't know, and I'm sorry I'm answering your question. No, that's okay. 11:41 [laughs] I don't know this off the cuff, and I would actually have to look it up because this is very specific, and we don't see this all the time. So I would need to look it up and let you know. This would be tough. 11:53 So in general, um, once you're, if you're divorced, you can't get DIC. If it's due to the PTSD, it is possible, but it's difficult. 12:05 It's very fact-specific, so it really depends, um-It really depends on whether you can prove that. You know, you'd have to prove that why you divorced and that it was due to the PTSD. 12:18 And after all this time, because it appears that it was before 1990, I don't know how much evidence you have left at this point. But, um, it is, it is not impossible to get that even though you were divorced. 12:31 And then, uh, because she was a widow again after she remarried in 1990, um, and became a widow again, you can still go back. That, that doesn't bar you because she's not married anymore. Um, you, you can reinstate that. 12:44 So, um, it is- I missed that part. Yeah... it, it is difficult, but not impossible. I, and it, and it is so fact-specific that I, I need more information to be able to answer that. All right. 12:59 E- EO, um, trying to get back increase ten percent service-connected from twenty years ago and have lumbar, lum- lumbar radiculopathy now. 13:10 Also trying to get service-connected knees denied twenty year- years ago and got out even though doc with eighty medical records. Going to file sup for knees. C&P didn't view C file and rater didn't factor in. 13:27 I was also a paratrooper. Left VA health for years. Recently went back to VA, got new X-rays, which showed degeneration. 13:38 I wanna pay private doctor to fill out DBQ for back increase and to get my knee service connected with n- Nexus as well. Is it okay if the exam is online if they use a digital... 13:50 I don't know, I don't know how to say that, but I know exactly what it is. Also, can I tell rater they don't need to schedule C&P because I'm already submitting DBQ, back and knees and Nexus? Heard this works sometimes. 14:06 Thank you. So there's a whole lot. Let's go back to number one. Let's piece this together. It's not that complicated, but I just don't wanna miss anything. Um, so you're just trying to get the back and the knees. 14:21 Um, let's answer the question about the, the DBQ and using online, um, tool. So it's a tool that measures, like, how much you can bend and things like that. Um, I don't know about using an online one. 14:37 I don't think I would do that. What you could do is go to a chiropractor and have someone actually do those measurements and have the chiropractor then give the measurements to the doctor who's doing the DBQ for you. 14:51 Um, and then you also have that kind of report to put in. I think that's gonna serve you much better than trying to do online testing. 15:00 You know, um, a lot of chiropractors do that kind of thing, so you could probably find one if the person doing your DBQ doesn't already have someone to do that. Um, let's go to the next one. 15:22 Okay. Um, I would just point out the things, um, like you're a paratrooper and things like that, just write a memo, put it on a forty-one thirty-eight kind of that you were a paratrooper. 15:34 Your, you know, back and your knees are, are showing some issues. That's really gonna be one of the easiest things you can do. Um, you can request that VA not schedule you for a C&P exam. 15:46 Um, and if there's enough evidence in the file to rate it, they're not supposed to order C&P exams, but they do, and they order exams for everything, even things that aren't necessary. 15:59 So if you get lucky and they don't schedule one, that's great. I'm gonna say that chances of you getting scheduled for an exam anyways is very, very high, but you can try it. Did I miss anything, Shannon? 16:14 No, I agree with you. Um, I'd, I, I would not be in love with an online, um, review for a physical condition like that where they have to measure the, the range of motion. 16:25 I, I mean, I know they can do it, but I, I don't think VA is gonna... They're not gonna be interested in having you do that. 16:32 Um, and also, you know, they're-- you're gonna want, if you're doing your back and you said you have radiculopathy now, you're gonna want them to look at that as well. 16:40 So I, I probably would not go with an online exam for that. I just, I think it would-- an in-person exam is gonna be a lot better. But, um, s-- a- and I also agree that C-- you're gonna get a C&P exam. 16:52 I think they're going to. So you're probably gonna get an, an in-person [chuckles] exam whether you want one or not. But, um, I, I would probably opt for an in-person, um, in the first place if it were me. Okay. 17:09 I think we've got the... Is this the same? Yeah. Yep. Next question. Okay. This one's from Timothy. 17:19 Is a VA Form twenty-one twenty-six eighty required to pl- apply for VA aid and attendance if your service-connected PTSD is rated at a hundred percent and your VA clinical psychologist noted in your medical records that 17:34 you require regular assistance with meal prep, m-medication management, hygiene, and safety related to your PTSD? Also note was the effect of my migraine, sleep apnea, and overactive 17:47 bladder, all service-connected, and how these conditions were impacting my ALDs as well. It's, uh, documented well, but they want to complete the twenty-one twenty-six eighty, which I completely understand. Okay. 18:01 So the question is, is one required? So I don't know. Not necessarily required from your doctor, uh, but VA will send that out for an exam and have their doctor fill one out or, or do an exa- uh, do that. 18:18 Um-If your, if your doctors will fill one out, I would ask them to. Uh, I think VA is very form-driven, and even if something isn't legally required, they still wanna see it in the file before they grant. 18:32 So if you can get one, I would say do one. Um, and then, like I said, they're gonna send it out for their own C&P exam as well, and then they will fill out that form as well or a version of it. 18:43 Um, but so I don't know if it's legally required. I don't think it is because I'm pretty sure I've had that granted without it. 18:51 But, um, if, if I'm do- if I'm developing a case, I'm gonna put one in the file just because VA likes to see them. 18:59 And if you're going to VA for treatment, a lot of times VA doctors won't fill those forms out, and so sometimes you can't actually get one in. 19:08 Um, and in that case, like Shannon said, they will just schedule an aid and attendance exam. Um, I like to get one in the file, um, from a, a private doctor normally. 19:25 DJBrown92, "Thanks for all you do to support veterans in our plight with VA." You are so welcome. "Can you repeat the statement that you provided to expedite BVA appeals? 19:39 Something to the effect, I waive my right to the one-year review period by the Board of Veterans Appeal. It may not be exactly as it worded, but it's sufficient to move the appeal." So 19:51 that's pretty much what you have to say. Um, that's what I would say. There's actually a waiver out there, um, that the board will send. It's called... It's from the Case Williams. 20:05 Um, I call it a Williams waiver, and once they docket your appeal, I believe they send you a letter with that waiver with it. 20:16 Um, but anything that says, "I waive my right to the one-year review, please move forward," will suffice. There's not exact wording that needs to be said. Excellent. Yeah, that works for me. Yep. 20:37 Okay, this question's from Chris A. "For migraines, I was also using very heavy pain meds to work. The records showed this. 20:44 I am claiming protected work environment from my supervisors, supervisors for earlier effective." I think my question got cut off. Okay. "One, my first CUE. 20:55 I filed for pes planus from a two thousand eleven decision that went back to two thousand nine. VA found CUE and granted it at thirty percent. 21:04 I also argued VA failed to consider extra scheduler for migraines because VA combined anxiety and a migraines again two thousand eleven. VA HLR agreed and said they would refer it. 21:16 The rater said that that is what extra scheduler looks like and I should appeal to the BVA if denied. 21:23 My questions are, in nineteen ninety-nine, I was discharged for complications of pes planus left foot plantar fasciitis, but my records showed right and left foot plantar fasciitis bilateral. 21:35 Achilles not rev- relieved by arch supports, pes planus not previously problematic, and maximum medical improvement with little or no relief. I am fighting for the fifty percent rating and an earlier effective date. 21:47 Due to the CUE being found, VA C&P exam checked no on boxes for p- marked pronation, and then yes in an entire section. 21:55 Can I argue it was reasonably raised in 'ninety-nine and all benefit of the doubt is to be resolved in favor of the veteran on the C&P exam since VA acknowledged the CUE? 22:05 Also, I may have an earlier effective date for TDIU because I met the scheduler criteria earlier because of this award." I am gonna admit I am a little bit lost in what the question is here. Um, are... I don't know. 22:23 I- Based on the information here, I'm not sure if you have an earlier effective date or not. I, I just... I'm missing some in-information. So reasonably raised, I think we can talk about that for a moment- Okay... 22:36 um, and kinda break down some of the parts and pieces that are in here. So if they found a CUE, and you're saying that it was just for one foot, but in your records you talk about... 22:50 And this is prior to the AMA and actually really prior to... 22:56 So in the legacy appeals system, which it sounds like all of this is, if you made a statement talking about your right foot or your left foot, and they only talk a-- like they only rate you on one of them, 23:08 you can argue a reasonably raised claim. They're hard to get, and you have to get VA to go, "Oh yeah, that really was a claim, and we really should have adjudicated it, but we didn't." 23:20 If they- Assuming they didn't, because I'm not sure they didn't make a decision on it at some point. Right. 23:26 Um, if they did make a decision at any point after that reasonably raised claim and it was a denial, that reasonably raised claim is then gone. Um, so it has to be you ra- you raised it, and it was reasonably raised. 23:41 No decision on it was ever made, no denial, and now you wanna say, "Hey, go ahead and adjudicate that claim." That can happen. Um, earlier effective date, I'm sorry, I just took this whole question over, Shannon. 23:56 No, go... Sorry. No, I said I, I, I, I got a little lost in the question, and I'm not sure what the, what it was. 24:03 And so for the earlier effective date of the TDIU, what I would say is from what I'm gathering, you've got the migraines and the feet, and you were granted TDIU on an extra scheduler basis, or you were trying to go for an extra scheduler basis. 24:20 And you now have TDIU from whatever point forward-And you wanna get an earlier effective date based on a protected work environment, and you're getting your bosses to write a statement. 24:34 If that is your, your, your case, like you're now at schedule or earlier, you're trying to get this protected work environment, I will caution you that protected work environment cases are now very difficult to win for, uh, TDIU, either effective dates or 24:52 just for granting of the entitlement. So before, if you worked in a sheltered environment and you worked for your boss and they made all these accommodations for you, you could get it. 25:05 But the courts went ahead and added a whole nother part to a protected work environment where they said you have to be sheltered and protected, but you also need to make less than a good wage essentially. 25:22 So it's above the poverty level, but it's still a lower income paying position. We don't know what lower income paying position means at this point. No one's sussed it out. 25:34 We don't know if that's lower for the person's education and previous jobs or if it's just kind of a number or percentage above the poverty level. 25:43 So if you're making thirty-five, forty thousand dollars a year, the chances of getting that protected and sheltered work environment is gonna be pretty low, just so that you know. Um, 25:56 and so I just did-- I wanted to touch on that. All the rest of it, I don't really understand the question or how it plays in, but those are the, the two things that I picked up. I'll take this one. 26:10 Do you wanna take this one since I took the last one [laughing]? [laughing] You read it, I'll answer it. There we go. All right. Okay. All right. Twenty nineteen, this is from Brock. 26:20 Twenty nineteen, found to have protein in urine, put on lisinopril. Twenty twenty two, diagnosed with s- chronic kidney disease stage two, and VA service-connected. 26:31 January twenty twenty-five, had a disagreement with my kidney doc and so made an appointment with a new kidney doc. New doc says labs recent and prior show normal kidney function, n-no CKD, and stop lisinopril. 26:47 Now I've got two different diagnosises and treatments in four months' time window. Should I get a third opinion or notify the VA that I may not actually have CKD? I would definitely... 26:59 Oh, sorry, you're answering this one. [laughing] Go ahead, Janice. This is a good one. 27:03 Um, I'm more concerned about your treatment in this situation because if one of your doctors is saying you have it and putting you on, uh, medication and the next one says you don't have it and is taking you off the medication, I probably want another opinion. 27:19 That's me personally. Um, e-especially if, I mean, I would not be notifying the VA that I don't have chronic kidney disease until I know for sure that I don't have chronic kidney disease. 27:29 And, um, so I would get another opinion. Um, if you find that you don't have it, uh, you know, then you can kind of figure out what you wanna do from there, whether that's to notify the VA or, um... 27:42 But I, yeah, I wouldn't be telling them anything until I knew for sure and had my diagnosis down and my treatment. That's me. Yeah, I, I agree. That's somewhat scary, and I, I think you do need to find out what you have. 27:58 Um, but there's no need at this point to notify the VA because you don't actually know. Okay, this one's from Roger S- All right, I'm reading. Are you reading? Okay. [laughs] I don't know where we are at this point. 28:12 [laughs] I'll read this que-- I'll read this question and answer it, and then we'll start from there. [laughs] Okay. Okay. This one is from Roger Smith. Thanks for all you do. 28:20 I was turned down for ED, erectile dysfunction, thirty percent heart disease, one hundred percent prostate cancer. How can I prove ED with a supplemental claim? It was a phone call for the ED claim. 28:30 I have never seen one hundred percent prostate cancer without ED. 28:35 I, I, not-- I mean, if you have it, I, I would say talk to your urologist, whoever's treating you for prostate cancer, and have them write a letter for you and say that the erectile dysfunction is related to the prostate cancer because I'm pretty sure it is. 28:50 Um, it, I mean, it usually when I see prostate issues, uh, it, they go hand in hand. It's very rare that they're gonna deny that. So, 28:59 uh, your doctor should be able to do a quick letter, or even if they don't wanna write a letter, ask them to put it in your medical records, and then you can just print a copy of the medical records and send that to the VA. 29:09 But, um, I would definitely appeal that with either the medical records or a letter. Yep. HL: My sleep apnea claim was finally approved after appealing several times. Yay. 29:26 But was combined with my sixty percent asthma VA rating, but the VA did not increase my asthma rating. Should I appeal this? Um, so if your asthma was at sixty percent 29:40 prior to the service connection for the sleep apnea, and then you were granted for the sleep apnea at fifty percent, this is one of those situations where I believe there should be a step up in the rating. 29:58 If you can prove that, it's difficult, but you have to prove... 30:03 So the asthma's the right, the higher rating, so you're not gonna get the sleep apnea and the asthma, but you can at times get a step up for the respiratory conditions. What you're gonna have to do is take the asthma 30:17 and say, "These are my symptoms of my asthma, and these are my symptoms of my sleep apnea, and while they're all kind of the same, they're distinct, and I should get a step up in my rating." 30:29 Um, there's only a couple ofConditions where you can kind of get that step up in rating, and I know sleep apnea and asthma is one of them. Um, but without knowing 30:42 more about that, it's difficult to say 60% for asthma i- is a, a high rating. Um, but you could try it. I would probably try it. What about you, Shannon? Well, I, I would say, first of all, I'm looking... 30:58 Whenever I see a 60% rating for a single condition, I'm also thinking unemployability. So if y- if you're not working, um, y- you know, you might wanna consider that as well. Um, but, 31:10 uh, respiratory ratings, you know, you, like you said, you can't necessarily... 31:15 A, a lot of them are grouped together so that you can't have separate ratings for them, but, uh, you do need to look at, um, does it, does it cause something different that you're not being compensated for. Yeah. 31:28 So you could increase it by getting the TDIU, get it up to 100 if you're not working. Okay, this one's Remy86. "Hello, I was granted SMCS housebound status two days ago for men- uh, major depressive disorder 70%. 31:45 I was wondering how would I qualify for SMCL. My son helps me with all my ADL, and I'm 50% for sleep apnea and 50% for migraines and 10% for bilateral shins, shin splints. 20% peripheral neuropathy, 100% P&T scheduler. 32:01 Thank you." Um, go back to the first part. So SMCL is aid and attendance, and you don't get both L and S. You would get the higher one, which would be L if you're, if you qualify for that. 32:15 Basically, aid and attendance, you need to look... If you're... You need to be, um, looking at what kind of help you need, at what kind of, uh, you know... Are you needing help getting dressed? 32:27 Are you needing help, um, with your daily activities? Um, s- specifically, when there's mental health involved, I'm looking at, um, you know, can you be left alone? Um, is it a danger to... 32:40 You know, is your environment a danger to you if you're left by yourself? Um, that's what you need to show. You're, you need help with your ADLs due to your service-connected condition. 32:50 So that's important to, to, uh, to make sure that you do that. So you just apply for aid and attendance. 32:58 There's a 2680 form that you can have your doctor fill out saying that you need help with these a- activities of daily living due to your service-connected condition. 33:08 Um, I do caution you that with mental health, you know, if that's what the primary, um, factor that's making you need these conditions, be aware that that's gonna raise a red flag for, uh, fiduciary and can... 33:20 Are you competent to handle your money? Always wanna make sure everybody knows that that kind of, that raises that flag for the VA if you're asking for aid and attendance and saying, "I can't be left by myself." 33:31 They're also gonna say, "Can you handle your money?" So, um, so that's also an issue. 33:36 But if your son is helping you with those things already due to your service-connected conditions, I'd say just you get that aid and attendance form and have your doctor fill it out and, and apply, uh, to VA with that. 33:47 If you just got SMCS two days ago, then you can probably still appeal and say that they didn't give you the right level of, uh, special monthly compensation. I agree with everything. 34:00 But Remy, I'd also like you to know that there's a caregiver program through the VHA that you can apply for. Um, and it's something that's a little different than the aid and attendance. 34:11 Um, it's harder to get than aid and attendance, even though it really shouldn't be. 34:16 But if he's helping you, um, it's a stipend that would get paid to your son for staying at the house and helping you do things that you need, whether it's medication management, showering, um, getting yourself dressed, and things like that. 34:30 So that's another program that you might wanna look into. And you can have both. Yes. Mm-hmm. Mike Allen, "Is there a separate form for a CAR higher-level review or just the same higher-level review form? 34:46 Do you have to write CAR on it in big letters?" So there is not a separate form for a CAR higher-level review. 34:53 CAR stands for Claims Accuracy Review, and it is designed for higher-level reviews where there's just a simple error, not an error in judgment or an error in, 35:07 you know, how they decided it, but let's say it's an effective date issue that's clearly just wrong. 35:12 They give the effective date of, you know, the supplemental claim and not the initial claim or from the claim date, not the intent to file. 35:21 Um, it's a little bit more restrictive than a higher-level review, so you can't have a conference. Um, I will be honest with you, I have not seen really any difference in CAR and higher-level reviews, just regular. 35:34 I don't think they're separating them out. I don't think they're going any special place. They are just higher-level reviews. You can try it. It's still gonna be a higher-level review. 35:47 The way that I do it, or when I did do it, I don't really do it now, is I just write Claims Accuracy Review in the top in big letters. So yes, that's exactly what I do. 35:59 Um, and even where-- And then I'll send kind of like a cover letter that says, "I'm doing this into the Claims Accuracy Review" in big letters. Um, but you're essentially just doing a higher-level review. I mean, 36:11 that's what you're doing. Yeah, I, I have, I have used them a few times if it's a really super, I mean, there's no question that they've made a mistake, they overlooked something. Um, they, 36:26 uh, sometime- a, a couple of times, they came back really, really fast, like a few weeks. 36:32 But a regular HLR is only taking a couple of months, so there's not that mu- you know, there's a few weeks difference in the processing time maybe.Um, but, uh, it's, uh, that is how you do them, though. 36:44 You write claims accur- accuracy review on them, so I don't know if they're that helpful. Okay, this one's Hollywood Sasquatch, "No question today, just a big thank you for the week after week help you give us all." 36:58 It is absolutely our pleasure. We actually really enjoy doing our jobs, so... We do. Do I have to answer the- That doesn't count. It wa- You still have to take each one. [laughs] It doesn't count. 37:08 [laughs] So this one's Itsthattime, part one of two. 37:12 "A decision to grant special monthly compensation at the L rate was a clear and unmistakable error, and special monthly compensation at the PM rate is granted based on aid and a- attendance from November 1st, 2022. 37:28 What is my SMC pay rate, SMC-P or SMC-M?" Go back. I mean, that was a good cue decision. They- Mm-hmm... they're paying more. So you're getting paid at the M rate. 37:46 There's no payment for P. Essentially, P is what they use to allow you to get to M. Okay. So you are being paid at the M rate. 37:55 P is just a provision under the special monthly compensation regulations that allows you to bump it up, so... Yeah. I'm curious, um, did, did you file that cue or did VA raise that on their own? 38:13 Yeah, that would be interesting to know. Yeah. 38:15 So, like, after the YouTube, if you wanna, like, write your answer, I can go back and check 'cause I, I'm very curious, um, you know, 'cause that, that's, that's awesome and amazing, and I'm glad you got that. 38:24 But you are being paid at the M rate. All right. We're gonna take, um... So we have to be done at 2:45 because we've got some client calls that we need to make and get ready for at 3:00. 38:34 So we're gonna take a couple more questions. We've got about six minutes, so we're gonna try to, like, get through as many as we can. All right. Ready? 38:45 FarmGirlRebel, "My VSO put in for insomnia when I told him I couldn't sleep due to pain. I didn't know this was a mental health, always assumed just pain management. 38:54 Is it going to harm me on my C&P with no mental health diagnosis?" Insomnia is actually a mental health diagnosis, and that's how it is rated. 39:04 Um, if you don't have an actual diagnosis in your records, the C&P can diagnose you with that if you're having trouble sleeping. 39:13 Um, and there's also a lot of other mental health con- well, I wouldn't say a lot, but we find that people who are in a lot of pain can also get other types of mental health conditions such as major depressive disorder. 39:28 There's somatic pain disorders, things like that, and, 'cause being in chronic pain can cause a lot of issues with your mental health, including insomnia, and the insomnia may just be a symptom of a bigger mental health issue that you have. 39:43 So I don't think that it hurts you. 39:46 Um, I think the VSO probably did you a favor for getting that in there, and I would definitely, if you're not following up with a doctor and you're not being able to sleep, you should follow up with a doctor. 39:58 Absolutely agreed. Okay, the next question's from Maritza, "Can you apply for SMC(r1) for severe PTSD for aid and attendance?" I don't know of any way to do that. I'm trying to think of, 40:20 uh... Uh, what do you think, Ursula? I'm, I'm, I'm thinking- The only way, the only way I... So (r1) is based on a lot of, like, loss of use, um, things. Your arms aren't working, your legs aren't working. 40:32 I don't think so. The only way I could possibly see getting paid at that (r1) level for a mental health issue is if that mental health issue is because of a TBI. 40:47 Then you could go for SMC(t) because your traumatic brain injury and the PTSD requires the aid and attendance, and without that, if you didn't have the aid and attendance at home, you would need specialized nursing care. 41:04 That would be the only way that I can see a mental health condition getting you to that (r1) rate is through T and a TBI. That's what- Yeah. I'm kinda, I'm kinda thinking the same. 41:15 I mean, it, it would have to be so severe that, I mean, that you'd need to be in a nursing home, but I, I don't, I don't... I can't think of a case where I've ever seen where that would be possible, but 41:29 I'm always happy to be proved wrong if somebody knows different. Yeah, me too. Werner, why do I get all the hard names to pronounce? [laughs] "Claims adjuster here. 41:42 Won't, won't listen to me on records are innocent and have meeting again in May. See what happens. Taking pictures with me this time. Have plenty of Super 8 films. Won't give them up." I... 41:56 Let's- So you're saying your records are incorrect, and you're trying to prove that they're incorrect with pictures and, and Super 8 films. Um, I mean, I think that could be done. I think it's gonna be hard. 42:11 I mean, you, it, you'd have to... They're gonna have to admit that what your pictures show is what you're saying they show. 42:17 So I, I don't know exactly what records are incorrect or what your pictures show, so I, I don't really know, um, what you can do there. 42:28 Statements in addi- addition to the pictures would probably help from anyone that knows anything. "Did they pass SB23 in California for property tax exemption?" I don't know. Yeah, I don't know. 42:46 We're in Florida. Um-Check with California. Um, also go to military.um... Is it org or gov? I forget. Military.org. I think that's org. 43:00 And they'll list out all of the exemptions and things like that that veterans get. But I don't- Yeah, I haven't heard. All right, I think this is gonna be our last one probably. Let's see. 43:12 Rudy Fuentes, "I received a letter telling me my pension was denied when I applied for disability. I only served four years. What should I do?" Um, 43:25 I- if the pen- if the question is about pension, um, so that's gonna be income-based, and you have to have served during wartime at least one day, um, there's other requirements. 43:36 So I don't know why they di- they denied it. Um, you, you probably wanna read the letter carefully and see what exactly it is they say you're missing. 43:45 Um, if, if this is pension, then it's non-service-connected pension, and that means, um, you know, you have to meet those qualifications for as far as income and, and when you served. 43:56 Um, if you're talking about service connection, a- again, let's see, I, I'm not su- that's all, um, I, I... You said pension, so I'm gonna assume it's the non-service-connected. 44:08 Yeah, I think he wanted to apply for compensation, but they gave him a pension decision, is what I picked up from that. So they need to adjudicate the compensation. Yeah, in that case, I would... 44:20 you send a letter and tell, you know, "You have not adjudicated my claim for compensation." All right, I think that gets us to the end of our session. We really appreci- appreciate your being here with us today. 44:32 Um, someone will be here with you next week to answer questions again. Thanks for joining us. Thank you for your service. 44:40 [outro music]